.png)
Today we're kicking off Season 18 by diving into the age-old question: does God really determine who you marry, and how do you navigate the pressure, theology, and decision-making in Christian dating?
Introduction
Untangling Soulmate Myths, God’s Will, and the Pressure We Put on Ourselves
The Burden of “The One” and Why Soulmate Theology Hurts
Over-Spiritualizing and Fear-Based Decision-Making
Idols, the Heart, and What We Hear from God
What Does the Bible Actually Say About Who to Marry?
A Mindset Shift: Pursue Wisdom, Not Perfection
Welcome to Season 18 of the Heart of Dating podcast! In today’s episode, we’re tackling one of the most ambiguous and pressing questions in Christian dating: Does God speak to us about who we’re supposed to marry? JJ and Kait dive into the confusing theology around “the one,” soulmate myths, and how over-spiritualizing decision-making can create pressure in the dating process. They explore what scripture actually says about discerning God’s will, how our own desires and idols can cloud our perception, and why wise counsel and biblical principles matter more than waiting for a supernatural sign. Whether you’re waiting for “the one” or wrestling with the concept of God’s sovereignty in your love life, this episode will empower you to move forward with clarity, faith, and intentionality.
We’re kicking off Season 18 with a BIG, juicy question: Does God actually speak to us about who we should marry? Is there “the one” out there, waiting to be revealed by a sign, a dream, or a neon arrow from heaven? Or are we putting WAY too much pressure on ourselves with “soulmate theology” and fear of missing God’s will? This is hands-down one of the most confusing and high-pressure topics for Christian singles, so let’s chat about it all!
First up, let’s just say it: Christian dating can feel like you’re playing emotional Jenga with God’s plan for your life. Too many of us grew up hearing that there’s just one “perfect” match out there, and if you miss them (or marry someone else), you’ve somehow doomed yourself (and possibly others!) to “less than” God’s best 01:13.
But where does that idea even come from? It’s not actually in the Bible, y’all! “Soulmate theology” has roots in Greek mythology, NOT God’s word. The myth says humans were split apart, and we roam the earth looking for our other half. As romantic as that may sound, it’s not biblical. If you mess up and marry the “wrong” soulmate, apparently you’ve thrown off the cosmic order for everyone 11:30. Not exactly the freedom Jesus bought for us.
Instead, this thinking:
No wonder dating feels scary.
So, what does over-spiritualizing look like? It’s when we need an angelic billboard before agreeing to a single date, or stall out waiting for “prophetic confirmation” of every relationship step 05:26. Honestly, this can keep us stuck and anxious rather than walking in faith and wisdom. One common result is inaction: we retreat to our couches, waiting for “the one” to ring the doorbell, instead of actively engaging, loving, and getting to know people as the Bible encourages 07:27.
The question underneath all this is: Are we trusting God with an open, surrendered heart? Or are we afraid we’re going to blow it if we make the “wrong” choice? Sometimes this pressure convinces us that we’ll wreck the plan if we don’t get it “right”.
The Bible offers a sobering check here: what you want most in your heart can actually influence what you think you hear from God. Ezekiel 14:4 pulses with this warning; if you come to God clinging to an idol—like the need for a particular relationship—He might allow you to hear what your heart is already set on 12:23. YIKES.
In other words, it’s totally possible to think “God told me” when, actually, it was our own deepest desire talking. The heart is deceitful above all things, meaning it can trick us, especially in these huge decisions 00:23.
How do you combat that? Come to God with a neutral heart: open to whatever answer He wants to give, truly willing to hear a “yes” or a “no” 15:47. Pair that with being rooted in Scripture (where God speaks to us most clearly!) 16:26, and surround yourself with wise counsel for major decisions 18:09.
Does the Bible ever actually say “God will reveal your one soulmate”? Nope. Instead, Scripture gives broad boundaries and essential characteristics for the kind of person we should marry. For example, someone with strong faith, godly character, and aligned values 17:23, 20:05.
Paul, talking to widows in 1 Corinthians 7, says she “is free to marry anyone she wishes, but he must belong to the Lord.” That’s surprisingly practical! God gives us freedom within wise boundaries. The “fence” is: do they love Jesus? Are they running after Him? Within that, you have freedom to choose 20:15.
Wisdom,not fate, guides us as we make decisions. Yes, wise counsel, prayer, and the Holy Spirit lead us, but it’s not a mystical treasure hunt for “the one and only.”
So if you’re wrestling with the pressure, or stalling out of fear you’ll get it wrong, breathe. Pursuing marriage as a “prize” will always leave you feeling like you’re failing if you’re single, or anxious you’ll miss God’s best. Instead, shift your focus to questions like:
Bottom line: God is less interested in micro-managing your spouse selection, and more interested in your heart posture, character, and growth. Even if you don’t choose perfectly, His grace covers your journey. He meets us in our mess, uses every story to point to Him, and calls us to walk in freedom, not fear 23:31.
You’ve got this, fam. Choose wisely, trust God, and live free!
OH! Check out the transcript!!: https://docs.google.com/document/d/11SaN3Ll0FLB8MhDxN9JRB5LhzTCzyP2vfapOXOxf8D0/edit?usp=sharing
Kait Tomlin is a best-selling author, speaker, popular relationship coach, and the founder of Heart of Dating. She helps thousands of men and women on their journeys through the conversations on the Heart of Dating Podcast, which launched in 2018.
Through her ministry, Kait’s mission is to empower both men and women to have the courage to own their story, walk in victory, thrive with purpose, and discover clarity and vision in their life and relationships. In her new book, Thank You for Rejecting Me: Transform Pain into Purpose and Learn to Fight for Yourself, Kait vulnerably shares how she grew through her deepest, darkest rejections and offers readers the tools to heal from the past, take back their power, and walk in strength, victory, and love into their future. Kait currently lives in the Los Angeles area with her husband JJ and their pups Lovey and Teddy. She loves sunshine, walks, Jesus, and lip syncing to Celine Dion.
JJ Tomlin is a missionary kid born in Belgium, originally from Tennessee, and currently residing in the OC. He currently works in Gaming/E-Commerce, enjoys watching his Tennessee Titans on Sundays with his Goldendoodle Teddy and loves working with Christian men to raise the bar in singleness and dating.

Stay up to date with all our latest episodes featuring fresh, compelling topics and guests weekly!