next episode
PodcastSCHOOL OF DATINGPatreonblogHamburger Navigation IconSearch Icon
0

Can God Really Satisfy Me?

with

Phylicia Masonheimer

Today Kait and JJ are joined by Phylicia Masonheimer to talk through the theology of singleness. 

Skip Ahead

In This Episode

Check Icon

Introduction

Check Icon

Not was not initially attracted to her husband, Josh and vice versa.

Check Icon

Check Icon

First, you are a woman of THEOLOGY, and I just love following along with you Phylicia. Can you share the BIBLICAL foundation of singleness?

Check Icon

How do we choose CHRIST over our human nature?

Check Icon

Tim Keller has a quote that says, marriage is to make you holy not happy. Would you say before you got married you might have known that idea, but in real life and how you lived, you were still putting that God-sized expectation of fulfillment and happiness on your spouse? How do you reconcile that?

Check Icon

One way I’ve heard unconditional love described is radical acceptance of wherever that person is at as they are right now, bearing one another’s burdens and weaknesses, is saying you do have burdens and weaknesses and I’m not trying to change a single thing about them. Do you think you can only extend that kind of radical acceptance if you’ve known that radical acceptance by God?

Check Icon

What if I’m a single who’s saying something along the lines of, I love God, I’ve been a Christian for 15 years, and I’m dating and I’m just not in a happy place. I feel really unsatisfied by my friendships, by the dating scene. If I had to be honest, people talk about being content and satisfied by God, and I just don’t really feel like he is satisfying me in that way.

Check Icon

GOD by his very nature cannot be UNSATISFYING- can you explain MORE about that? What does it mean if we are being consistently, dissatisfied by God?

Check Icon

What would you suggest for people who are feeling stagnant in their relationship with the Lord?

Introduction

Hello Heart of Dating family!!! We’re back this week with another episode in season 12 all about tools to THRIVE in singleness. Today we THRILLED to have the one and only Phylicia Masonheimer with us. She’s the CEO of Every Woman a Theologian where she seeks to teach and communicate theology to the everyday person. You guys, if you don’t know who Phylicia is you need to RUN to go follow her. She’s incredibly smart and knows so much about the Bible! Today she’s sharing her wisdom and wealth of knowledge with us as we unpack a biblical foundation of what singleness is and the theology of singleness. This episode is going to be so informative and FUN! Let’s dive in! 

Not was not initially attracted to her husband, Josh and vice versa.

Phylicia and Josh had a lot of wise counsel at the time who encouraged them that attraction grows as love grows and love grows as you see their character. She’s quick to note that this doesn’t go for every single relationship but it CAN happen and it did for both her and Josh. 

What kept you going in those first few weeks and dates when the physical attraction wasn’t catching up as much as you hoped or expected it would? 

Common vision and common values. They weren’t talking about what kind of music and movies they like. They actually don’t like the same movies and music as each other. What they learned is that you can form common interests that you didn’t have before together, but it’s really hard to form common values and vision. They kept coming back to both wanting to build their lives on God. 

First, you are a woman of THEOLOGY, and I just love following along with you Phylicia. Can you share the BIBLICAL foundation of singleness?

We often talk about marriage as this picture of the gospel which leaves a lot of singles feeling like they can’t picture the full picture of the gospel because they’re only half of something. That’s kind of the way it’s presented theologically. YET, the Bible is extremely supportive and positive about singleness. We see in scripture people who were single and doing amazing things, not the least of which is JESUS himself. Paul talks extensively about singleness in Corinthians. Sometimes people pull parts of that scripture out to pressure people into getting married for sex. Really what Paul is saying that there are seasons and callings and we don’t know how long they last. In these different seasons there are different ways to picture the gospel. Singleness is one way to picture the gospel and to walk out this beautiful dependence on God that leads to world impact. AND you also have to depend on God in marriage. 

Corinthians is really the biggest section in scripture where we really see that God thinks what singles are doing is important, and their ability to minister to others, to influence their world is powerful, EVEN WHILE, it can also be painful. These two things aren’t separate. Singleness might feel like a gift and a trial at the same time and that is okay. 

How do we choose CHRIST over our human nature?

Pylicia says that she thinks we first have to start with a few assumptions that we have about satisfaction in God, choosing Christ in the face of these desires. Our desire for companionship and marriage is not bad. God instituted communion in the form of marriage at the beginning before the fall. He said it’s not good for man to be alone and that it’s not good for humanity to be alone. We NEED other people. BUT, what we’ve done is taken that passage and we’ve said well that means that the only way we can get community is through marriage. 

So then what happens is you have a mentality that you need to find someone who’s going to fill this void for you. What happens when you have that mentality and then get married is that it doesn’t actually go away. Then in a few years you find out that one person can’t carry all of that because they’re not designed to. 

We need to back up and see why we’re not satisfied and it’s because we’re putting too much on the institution of marriage. That other person is NOT there to satisfy you. Before we can choose Christ over our human nature and be satisfied in God, we have to remember that epeople who are married have to be satisfied in God too.  

Tim Keller has a quote that says, marriage is to make you holy not happy. Would you say before you got married you might have known that idea, but in real life and how you lived, you were still putting that God-sized expectation of fulfillment and happiness on your spouse? How do you reconcile that?

Marriage should make you happy, you will be attracted to  your spouse, and you will become holy through it. Deep down Phylicia and Josh thought that a Christian marraige should result in x, y, z. We have to objectively step back and see if these things need to be happening according to scripture OR is this a preference? Is this really a sin issue that needs to be confronted or is this a preference? Be realistic about what you’re expecting from a fellow human. 

One way I’ve heard unconditional love described is radical acceptance of wherever that person is at as they are right now, bearing one another’s burdens and weaknesses, is saying you do have burdens and weaknesses and I’m not trying to change a single thing about them. Do you think you can only extend that kind of radical acceptance if you’ve known that radical acceptance by God?

Phylicia thinks so because only when you’ve experienced God’s radical acceptance does it come also with his discerning wisdom. In the Christian dating world on one side of the spectrum you don’t want to settle for someobody who doesn’t share your values or love God. On the other end of the spectrum we have these unrealistic expectations that we ourselves don’t even fulfill. In the middle is God saying, I accept you, I love you as you are, but I’ve also given you my Holy Spirit so you can discern weather this person has a heart for me and can walk with you as you both grow. 

What if I’m a single who’s saying something along the lines of, I love God, I’ve been a Christian for 15 years, and I’m dating and I’m just not in a happy place. I feel really unsatisfied by my friendships, by the dating scene. If I had to be honest, people talk about being content and satisfied by God, and I just don’t really feel like he is satisfying me in that way.

When singles struggle with loneliness, disappointment, discouragement, they often feel that marrieds can’t understand. This comes from that misunderstanding that when you get married, that person is satisfying you all the time, that they’re fulfilling you and therefore you don’t ever feel lonely or disappointed or discouraged. BUT, when you’re in a marriage with another flawed human it is possible to actually feel equally as isolated, lonely, discouraged, and disappointed, partially because no one belives that you can feel that way when you are married. 

There’s a lot more in common between singles and married on this and they should be able to have conversations about God’s satisfaction because you will need it in marriage just as much as you need it when you’re single. In moments of discouragement and loneliness it’s an opportunity to realize that no human can fill that void, no human was meant to fill that void and it turns us to dependency on God. 

GOD by his very nature cannot be UNSATISFYING- can you explain MORE about that? What does it mean if we are being consistently, dissatisfied by God?

Phylicia says that she thinks it points to a contractual relationship. We often treat God in this way that says I’ll do this if you give me x, y, or z. We say, well, I’m back again, because I’m lonely. BUT, really if we had walked with him every step of the way, every hour, every day, every hour in intimacy of prayer and ongoing conversation with him, in the word, in godly community, then we experience a deeper satisfaction in him, even while walking through really hard emotions. 

What would you suggest for people who are feeling stagnant in their relationship with the Lord?

The experience of being single longer is very specific. What scripture tells us is that there are certain principles about God about the walk of faith that are universal to all Christians. If it’s feeling stagnany, it can be a lot of things. It’s okay to sit with things, be disappointed and mourn and lament. AND he has also promised to supply all of our needs and with the riches of Christ Jesus. Even Paul said, I asked God to take away this thorn in my flesh three times and God said no. He said, my grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness. Grace is giving power to the powerless. 

The tendency for some singles to say, fine God, you know what, I’m going to be so satisfied in you that I”m going to completely ignore my desire for a companion. What would you say to this person? 

In this case you’re spiritually bypassing your own desires. You are being honest. We do this when we are so hurt and disappointed that we can’t even look at it anymore. 

You can say you’re putting the desire away for him, but he iddn’t ask you to do that. He’s the one who’s saying, I didn’t ask you to say you didn’t want it. I didn’t ask you to lie to yourself or to me about this. I just wanted you to trust me with it. He’s not asking you to ignore it in order to be more spiritual. 

There’s going to be a limit on your intimacy with God if you think you are hiding something from him or withholding it from him. Until that withholding is done and you have said, God, I am desperate for you, I can’t do this on my own. There will always be a wall in your spiritual intimacy with him. And as long as there’s a wall there’s not going to be that satisfaction. 

Not just theologically speaking, but experientially, in day-to-day life, as a single or as a married, or as a divorcee, regardless of relationshipstatus…how does God begin to satisfy that innate desire for companionship? 

God uses a lot of different things and people to minister to us and to minister to those desires. Phylicia believes that we have sexualized physical touch, things like physical touch to the point that we don’t relaize that one of the ways God fulfills that in any season of life, is that he fulfills that through godly community. Safe, healthy, support form your community, including physical affection, is one of the ways God ministers to us and satisfies us. God works through the church, he works through human begins as a way to give us that compansionship. 

Headshot of Phylicia

Phylicia Masonheimer

Website IconPodcast Mic IconInstagram IconFacebook IconLinkedIn IconTick Tok IconTwitter IconYoutube IconYoutube IconCustom Icon

Phylicia Masonheimer is founder of Every Woman a Theologian, an online ministry teaching
Christians how to know what they believe, live it boldly and communicate it graciously. She
is an author, blogger and host of the chart-topping podcast Verity with Phylicia
Masonheimer. Phylicia and her husband Josh live in Petoskey, MI, with their three children
Adeline, Geneva and Ivan.

Website IconPodcast Mic IconInstagram IconFacebook IconLinkedIn IconTick Tok IconTwitter IconYoutube IconCustom Icon

Website IconPodcast Mic IconInstagram IconFacebook IconLinkedIn IconTick Tok IconTwitter IconYoutube IconCustom Icon

Website IconPodcast Mic IconInstagram IconFacebook IconLinkedIn IconTick Tok IconTwitter IconYoutube IconCustom Icon
Share this episode
Headshot of Kait Warman

Never Miss an Episode

Let’s clear through the dating fog together.

Stay up to date with all our latest episodes featuring fresh, compelling topics and guests weekly!

Meet us on the Gram!

White close sign

Looking for something specific?