next episode
PodcastBasics of DatingSchool of Dating1:1 CoachingHamburger Navigation IconSearch Icon
0

But What If I’m Not Attracted?

with

Kait and JJ

Today we're digging into the myth of instant chemistry as Kait and JJ unpack why moderate attraction matters, challenge Disney-style romance expectations, and share stories (including their own) about how attraction can genuinely grow over time!

Introduction

Hey HOD fam! We’re diving back into our “Navigating The Gray Zone” series with a topic that always stirs up strong reactions: What if you’re dating someone amazing…but just not that attracted to them? Kait and JJ are back, and they’re not afraid to challenge the Disney fairytale narrative we’ve all secretly held onto. If you’ve ever wondered how much attraction really matters (or what “settling” even means), buckle up because we’re getting real about desire, expectations, and the cultural scripts that shape our dating lives.

Why Does “Attraction” Hit So Deep?

  • From the jump, JJ pokes the bear: Why do people get so triggered around this? Turns out, attraction is tangled up with big stuff: desirability, worth, fear of rejection, and identity itself [03:04].
  • Many of us crave that “obsessed from the start” Disney moment,  and anything less can feel like a threat to our value as a partner [05:44].
  • There’s a myth that if someone wasn’t immediately infatuated, it means you’re less than, or they “settled.” Spoiler: that’s not the reality for most long-term, happy couples [06:30].

Moderate Attraction: The Underdog

  • Forget fireworks! Studies — and real-life relationships — show that moderate attraction is actually better for healthy, long-term love. Why? It’s stable, it lasts, and it’s not built on shifting sands [00:54, 26:57].
  • Attraction is a spectrum! It isn’t binary and it can grow over time, especially for women, as they get to know someone’s character, faith, and personality [12:09, 17:44].

How Culture Distorts Our Desires

  • Our standards have been hijacked by media, dating apps, and (let’s be real) porn; especially for men. That “10 out of 10” ideal? It’s not based in real life, and it’s probably keeping you from great relationships [12:41].
  • Women get told to “just be open and give him a chance,” while guys are pressured to chase only the most conventionally attractive options. Let’s call out those double standards! [18:28, 18:42]

So What Counts as “Settling”?

  • Settling is saying, “I guess this is as good as it gets, so I’ll just accept it.” But functionally, there’s a baseline: we say don’t go for less than a 3.1/5 in physical attraction. Anything lower just isn’t sustainable for romance or partnership [23:13, 24:02].
  • Give it time, about three months max, for attraction to grow (especially if all the other “buckets” like personality, faith, and emotional connection are there). But if it’s not rising, it’s okay to move on without guilt [24:21].

Beyond Looks: The Five Buckets of Attraction

  1. Spiritual
  2. Emotional
  3. Intellectual
  4. Personality
  5. Physical

If one is low, the others can help “raise the tide”. But don’t expect to find a 5/5 in every slot. Happily-ever-after is built on connection, safety, and shared values more than raw chemistry [15:37, 16:22].

Men Pursue, Women Respond: Why the Dynamic Matters

  • There’s beauty and wisdom in the traditional pattern of men pursuing and women responding. It mirrors the way Christ pursues us. Women often need time to “warm up,” while men tend to need a stronger initial spark to drive pursuit [20:14, 21:05].
  • If a guy isn’t sure after the first few months? That’s a good sign it’s not a match. And women: you don’t have to convince anyone to be into you! Your value doesn’t hang on someone else’s indecision [22:06].

If You’re Facing This Gray Area…

  • Start by checking your own standards: are they set by God and your real values, or by Instagram, Hollywood, and old hurts?
  • Focus on the other buckets! Sometimes attraction lags behind but can catch up as you feel spiritually, emotionally, and intellectually connected [24:09].
  • But if, after a few months, you can’t imagine ever wanting to kiss them, it’s loving and honest to let go and keep waiting for the right fit. Not the “perfect” 10, but a healthy mix of connection and desire [24:21]

The Takeaway

Physical attraction isn’t everything, but it does matter. The myth that you need instant fireworks sets us up for disappointment, but the opposite extreme isn’t helpful either. Moderate attraction, paired with strong character and connection, is actually the solid ground for lifelong love. Don’t let the world’s standards set your course, and don’t be afraid to do the slow-burn thing. Sometimes, the real spark grows after the first impression.

Shoutout to our behind-the-scenes team: Scott Caro (audio/video wizard) and Alana Gibson (brand/community queen)!

Got thoughts or reactions to this episode? Leave us a review on iTunes or Spotify, and share it with a friend who needs some real talk about dating “in the gray.” See you next week, HOD fam!

Headshot of Kait

Kait Tomlin

Website IconPodcast Mic IconInstagram IconFacebook IconLinkedIn IconTick Tok IconTwitter IconYoutube IconYoutube IconCustom Icon

Kait Tomlin is a best-selling author, speaker, popular relationship coach, and the founder of Heart of Dating. She helps thousands of men and women on their journeys through the conversations on the Heart of Dating Podcast, which launched in 2018.

Through her ministry, Kait’s mission is to empower both men and women to have the courage to own their story, walk in victory, thrive with purpose, and discover clarity and vision in their life and relationships. In her new book, Thank You for Rejecting Me: Transform Pain into Purpose and Learn to Fight for Yourself, Kait vulnerably shares how she grew through her deepest, darkest rejections and offers readers the tools to heal from the past, take back their power, and walk in strength, victory, and love into their future. Kait currently lives in the Los Angeles area with her husband JJ and their pups Lovey and Teddy. She loves sunshine, walks, Jesus, and lip syncing to Celine Dion.

JJ Tomlin

Website IconPodcast Mic IconInstagram IconFacebook IconLinkedIn IconTick Tok IconTwitter IconYoutube IconCustom Icon

JJ Tomlin is a missionary kid born in Belgium, originally from Tennessee, and currently residing in the OC. He currently works in Gaming/E-Commerce, enjoys watching his Tennessee Titans on Sundays with his Goldendoodle Teddy and loves working with Christian men to raise the bar in singleness and dating.


Headshot of JJ Tomlin

Website IconPodcast Mic IconInstagram IconFacebook IconLinkedIn IconTick Tok IconTwitter IconYoutube IconCustom Icon

Website IconPodcast Mic IconInstagram IconFacebook IconLinkedIn IconTick Tok IconTwitter IconYoutube IconCustom Icon
Share this Blog
Headshot of Kait Warman

Never Miss an Episode

Let’s clear through the dating fog together.

Stay up to date with all our latest episodes featuring fresh, compelling topics and guests weekly!

Meet us on the Gram!